[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: (ET) Testing lift motor at higher voltages



A now deceased mentor and friend of mine shared with me a neophyte motor pool experience he witnessed while stationed as a Cold Warrior in Germany.The New Guy in the Motor Pool was checking the oil in a Deuce and a Half that had a 24 volt electrical system. Somehow he managed to miss the target for the dipstick.What he DID find was the always hot battery cable connection for the starter. A brilliant flash, a loud bang, and the remains of the dipstick were found on the garage floor. Three pieces, still glowing yellow/red. :)

RJ


On 12/23/2012 7:48 PM, Christopher Zach wrote:
Hm. I'm remembering when I dropped a wrench across the 36 volts of my
BB600's in an outside tray and watched as the 100a "automotive type" fuse
exploded into a pretty plasma ball. The only thing that stopped it was my
kicking the wrench off the pack (the box had two rows of 18 cells with the
fuse in the middle between the rows. The arc jumped the fuse and was 
merrily
burning away at the copper towards the nickel battery terminals. Still have
the batts)

It... Could not... clear 36 volts at 1,000 amps. I now have 1,000 AIR rated
fuses on all the key battery interconnects.

Chris

-----Original Message-----
From: RJ Kanary [mailto:rjkanary consolidated net]
Sent: Sunday, December 23, 2012 7:39 PM
To: Christopher Zach; et
Subject: Re: (ET) Testing lift motor at higher voltages

            Thirty-six volts is the maximum rating for most automotive
switchgear currently.The much touted move to a 42 volt nominal automotive
electrical system has apparently been held up by difficulty with arc
quenching in switchgear and circuit protection devices.

RJ

On 12/23/2012 7:28 PM, Christopher Zach wrote:
That's because the internal breaker is rated for 12 volts. No problem
there,
it can probably open a 12 volt shorted load all day.

18 volts less so, 30 volts and it isn't going to happen :-) But you need
30a
at 12-18 volts to lift things.

I'll see how it does with a 20, might de-rate the fuse to 15a. There
wouldn't happen to be a breaker that fits in an ABC fuse slot and is rated
to break a 36 volt load, is there?

C

-----Original Message-----
From: RJ Kanary [mailto:rjkanary consolidated net]
Sent: Sunday, December 23, 2012 7:24 PM
To: Christopher Zach; et
Subject: Re: (ET) Testing lift motor at higher voltages

Bear in mind that the Delco motor has a high failure rate with the
internal
circuit breaker. On occasion, one will fail open.Unfortunately,the vast
majority of them weld shut.In the time it takes for the 30A Slo BloR fuse
to
open however, permanent damage has occurred.The primary job of THAT fuse
is
to protect the wiring, not the load.
I have replaced the fuse with a 15 or 20A self-resetting circuit breaker
to
stave off that type of disaster.

RJ


On 12/23/2012 6:41 PM, Christopher Zach wrote:
Well, keep in mind that the lift motor does not have permanent
magnets. It's actually a series wound motor with two field windings.
The power path goes from the battery, to the switch, to one or the
other field, to the armature, and then back to the battery.

The result is the motor **is** a series motor, so as the load
increases the draw on the field and armature increases as well.
Likewise if you double the voltage you double the field strength and
the armature strength so power output doubles.

I think the key danger is heat; more power means more heat in the
motor and too much heat will short out the windings as the insulation
melts. However if it can get the blower lifted in 3 seconds instead of
10-15 (what it takes when it's struggling at 18
volts) then that could mean the motor suffers **less** damage at 30
volts than 18. Maybe.

Chris

*From:*Rob Brockway [mailto:getractor yahoo com]
*Sent:* Sunday, December 23, 2012 6:31 PM
*To:* Christopher Zach; Elec-Trak
*Subject:* Re: (ET) Testing lift motor at higher voltages

I don't know how accurate this is, but I have heard that a lot of DC
motors are designed so they have a 50% voltage safety factor so you
don't demagnetize the permanent magnets. So a 12 volt motor design
will likely demag at 18 volts or higher (at locked armature amps).
Interestingly if you demagnetize the motor speed will tend to increase
under light load.

Rob

*From:*Christopher Zach <cz alembic crystel com
<mailto:cz alembic crystel com>>
*To:* Elec-Trak <elec-trak cosmos phy tufts edu
<mailto:elec-trak cosmos phy tufts edu>>
*Sent:* Sunday, December 23, 2012 4:16 PM
*Subject:* (ET) Testing lift motor at higher voltages

So this afternoon I had to switch the E20 over from mowing to
snowblower. Note that it is **much** easier to do when you put the
snowblower on two moving dollies. They're a good height, and it's a
snap to roll the thing around the shed.

At the same time I figured I would try to boost the voltage draw for
my lift motor. Normally it's tapped to 18 or so volts on the BB600
pack, right about the middle. The next closest battery terminal would
be 30 volts, so I gave that a shot.

**wow**. Motor zips up and down fast, lifts deck as if it was not
there. So I removed the deck and put on the snowblower. Greased the
lift pulley and gave it a shot.

**wow**. Motor zips up and down fast, lifts snowblower as if it was
not there. This is good, as normally the motor struggles to lift the
blower and sometimes stalls. Now it runs it right up in a few seconds.
In fact I worry that I will rip something out if it hits the highest
lift point. So I reduced the lift fuse from 30a to 20a.

Now, this is a "new" lift motor from Bill Gunn, top of the line. Not
sure how long it's going to last with this, but I did note that it's
duty cycle is now a lot less since it's not farting around struggling
to lift. Zip it's up in 3-4 seconds. Then off.

So now I am thinking: One of the big problems with the lift is that
the motor will stall out sometimes and then trip it's breaker.
Stalling a DC motor puts a lot of strain on the commutator bars and
the brushes. Is it better to have the motor still spinning (and pretty
quickly I might add) at 2.5 times it's rating? Seems like it would be
drawing less current, which is good. So what's the downside?

I wonder what the switch in the lift is rated at. If I'm opening and
closing way above its rating, that might blow up.

Chris


_______________________________________________
Elec-trak mailing list
Elec-trak cosmos phy tufts edu <mailto:Elec-trak cosmos phy tufts edu>
https://cosmos.phy.tufts.edu/mailman/listinfo.cgi/elec-trak



_______________________________________________
Elec-trak mailing list
Elec-trak cosmos phy tufts edu
https://cosmos.phy.tufts.edu/mailman/listinfo.cgi/elec-trak